3D Printing vs. Injection Molding: When Each One Makes Sense

3D printing usually costs less for anything from one part up to a few hundred. Injection molding wins once you need thousands of the same part and the design is final, because the mold cost gets spread over every piece.

Why the two price differently

Injection molding needs a mold before the first part. A simple mold commonly costs $3,000 to $10,000, and complex steel molds cost far more. After that, each part might cost cents. 3D printing has no mold, so the first part costs about the same as the hundredth, but each part costs more.

A worked example

Say a part costs $8.67 each to print, and a molder quotes a $5,000 mold plus $0.50 per part. These are illustration numbers, so use your own quotes.

  • Break-even = mold cost / (printed price minus molded price)
  • $5,000 / ($8.67 minus $0.50) = about 612 parts

Below roughly 600 parts, printing costs less in total. Above it, molding starts to pay off, as long as the design does not change. Every design change can mean a new or modified mold.

Speed

A mold typically takes weeks to make, and longer if it is built overseas. A printed part can ship the next business day. If you need parts this week, printing wins regardless of quantity.

Design freedom

Molding needs draft angles, even wall thickness and no undercuts without extra mold actions. Printing does not care about most of that, and changing the design is just a new file. That makes printing the better choice while a design is still moving.

Strength and finish

Molded parts are fully solid and have smooth surfaces. Printed parts show fine layer lines and are strongest along the layers. For most brackets, knobs, clips and housings that is fine. For high-load or cosmetic retail parts at volume, molding is better.

A common path

  1. Print prototypes until the design is right. See rapid prototyping.
  2. Print the first production run while sales prove demand.
  3. Move to a mold once volume clearly passes break-even.

Not sure where your part lands? Ask us. If molding makes more sense for your quantity, we will say so. Or see what 3D printing really costs.